SUBSCRIBE:

No-win no-fee lawyers are a threat to the success of local government equal pay negotiations

This article first appeared in Personnel Today magazine. Subscribe online and save 20%.

Trade unions and employers have launched a blistering attack on so-called no-win, no-fee lawyers, accusing them of hijacking local government equal pay negotiations.

Employers' organisations have branded the lawyers "the biggest threat" to achieving harmonious settlements during an equal pay crisis that is threatening to overwhelm councils.

More than 5,000 claims have been made against local authorities in the North East alone, resulting in compensation in excess of £100m.

Speaking at an equal pay conference in London last week, Mick Brodie, director of the North East Regional Employers Organisation, warned: "No-win, no-fee claims for equal pay is not a North East problem - it's a national one."

Unions have particularly targeted Stefan Cross, a solicitor based in Newcastle, who has represented hundreds of women working for councils as cleaners, carers and clerical staff in the North East and in Scotland. Cross said he had more than 20,000 cases on his books in Scotland alone, with the potential for another 50,000. Each claimant could receive between £15,000 and £20,000.

Brian Strutton, national secretary at the GMB union, said: "Stefan Cross is not interested in achieving equal pay going forward, but only in making a fast buck from back-pay awards."

Public sector union Unison has reminded its members in Scotland that lawyers such as Cross are "in business to make money".

But Cross said employers and unions were conniving to withhold thousands of pounds in back pay legally due to women workers.

"Deals are being negotiated between male union reps and male employers, and female workers are being kept in the dark," he told Personnel Today. "Women have been discriminated against in local government for 30 years and these people are only interested in maintaining the status quo."

His comments come a fortnight after Local Government Employers warned that local authorities may collectively end up paying as much as £5bn in back pay to female workers.

By Natalie Cooper and Ross Bentley




 


COMMENTS

 
Predatory lawyers and 'no-brainer' equal pay cases
Predatory lawyers like Stefan Cross seem to be getting rich on 'no-brainer' equal pay cases where the hard work of finding comparators and demonstrating equal value has already been done at councils where pay and grading reviews have been completed. Councils that haven't completed reviews might now be tempted to limit their exposure to such claims by drawing 'pay lines' that minimises the extent to which the pay of predominantly female low paid jobs is levelled up and the number of those jobs.

John Fricker
06 Dec 2006
Local Government Equal Pay Negotiations

Far from being a threat to the success of local government equal pay negotiations, Stefan Cross and other lawyers are the best hope that women employees have. Does anyone seriously believe that the old gender-biased practices would be seriously tackled if local authorities (and other parts of the public sector) weren't being hit with individual claims?
The past 30 years suggests not, and that is the amount of time the employers and unions have had to sort this out. If anything, this whole episode suggests that public sector unions are no friend to the millions of low-paid women they represent. It is actually quite sickening to hear the unions’ (male) leaders attacking those who ARE actually helping women. Yes, the lawyers will be taking a slice of the money they gain for their clients - but it's money the women wouldn't have had anyway if it had been up to the unions!

Erik Kucjynski
06 Dec 2006
CommentComment on this Article in HR Space (Sign-in required)

ALERTS

Alert me when new articles are added on:
Equal pay
Diversity / Equal opportunities

RELATED RESOURCES

XpertHR, part of the XpertHR Group, brings together the expertise of IRS, LexisNexis Butterworths, CELRE, Personnel Today and a dedicated team of experts to meet the information needs of the busy HR professional.

 
© Reed Business Information 2008