SUBSCRIBE:
You are in: Home > Latest News

This article first appeared in Personnel Today magazine. Subscribe online and save 20%.

Diversity must be taken away from HR, equalities tsar Trevor Phillips has insisted.

The chairman of the Commission for Equality and Human Rights (CEHR), which will be officially launched on 1 October, said that with globalisation and changing populations, employers needed to ensure that all staff - not just those in HR - take responsibility for diversity.

Specialist practitioners should work outside existing departments to embrace diversity across an organisation's workforce, products and services, and this was "no longer the sole province of HR", said Phillips.

He told Personnel Today: "Diversity practitioners could monitor diversity practices, or act as internal consultants, to involve every department, including HR.

"Most organisations are beginning to realise they need a better understanding of how to deal with difference in a whole range of departments, which is why diversity is coming out of HR," he added.

Senior HR diversity practitioners agreed with Phillips that diversity was too big a job to stay in the HR function for long.

Npower diversity and inclusion head Nick Smith said: "When diversity sits in HR there will be some people who shrug their shoulders and say 'it is just another HR initiative'."

Mary Shaw, head of equality and diversity at the Ministry of Justice, agreed.

"Diversity is not just about staff it is also externalfacing and about how an organisation supports diversity and equality, and also the way it runs its business," she said.

However, Julie Dennis, head of diversity at the Land Registry, said that while diversity should be a business-wide concern, keeping it in HR would give it more short-term credibility.

And the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) warned of the potential pitfalls in creating a new function.

CIPD diversity adviser Dianah Worman said: "The challenge is about what kind of people become specialists. One of the problems in having a separate specialism is getting everyone on board."

CIPD says new diversity body would be 'too much too soon'

The CIPD has warned against a "gung-ho" approach to setting up a new professional body for diversity practitioners.

Learning and Skills Council (LSC) research found that 80% of 1,500 practitioners wanted a new association to help standardise the profession, accredit diversity qualifications, and map out proper career paths for practitioners.

The LSC will put the findings of the report, backed by CEHR chairman Trevor Phillips, to government policy makers later this year.

But CIPD diversity adviser Dianah Worman told Personnel Today: "Creating a new body for diversity is naïve, and too much too soon." She said forming a new association would be a "gung-ho approach" and more research was required.


COMMENTS

 
Diversity Issues

I become rather saddened in many ways when I watch the arguments on Diversity Issues as so many of the comments made are just wasted talk and from what I have observed and learnt over the years can be termed often as just "Lip Service".


I have worked in many parts of the world and been at the heart of what really goes on in peoples minds and the whole topic of Diversity has hardly had the surface even scratched here in the UK.


Legislation and Laws are the sticks to beat those blatantly being either Rascist or Discriminatory in whatever form but unfortunately it is what exists in the Psyche of people that must somehow be tackled.


We can watch HR people jumping around in order to see that their Policies and Procedures are being adhered to and we can see the many groups purporting to act for Diversity in so many arenas but none ever get to the real root of the problem which is inbred thinking patterns in the mind.


The whole pattern that needs looking closely at is why do people think the way that they do, Why do some have vendettas against women and why would some have bad feeling against men ?   Why would so many have Rascist  feelings and then again in reverse why would so many Minorities harbour such deep feelings about western or white people ?


I have found over the years that most problems come down to mutual respect for one another.  I could write a book on myself when in the Middle East and just helping some Asian People.Thai People and some Filipino groups into some decent accommodation that their appreciation was unbelievable and I was almost revered and the work effort increased substantially.


But this mutual respect must be earnt and other factors get in the way such as Terrorist Acts which darken feelings towards others or groups taking benefits that they should not get does not help the mindset.  Then others who appear to have nice homes while others appear to be suffering and then there is the situation where others appear to have treatment better than another group and so it goes on.  It is all the little inequalities that need to be swept out to start with and then some mutual respect to be generated which will not be easy.


I have talked very openly to so many Nationalities as well as Females and many others and this underlying "Hearts and Minds" is at the centre of the problems, not what is said but what is thought and often unsaid but often the hidden actions are never fully realised.


The Law is a protector but not an answer and the answer does not lie in people shouting from the Roof Tops of how much they love each other, or do they ? 


I am sure that I could set out some ideas to start the healing process but it could take time and really who wants to listen ?


John Hooley
21 Aug 2007
CommentComment on this Article in HR Space (Sign-in required)

EMAIL ALERTS

Alert me when new articles are added on:
 Diversity
 Diversity / Equal opportunities

RELATED RESOURCES

XpertHR, part of the XpertHR Group, brings together the expertise of IRS, LexisNexis Butterworths, CELRE, Personnel Today and a dedicated team of experts to meet the information needs of the busy HR professional.

 
© Reed Business Information 2009