Belief discrimination

Protection against discrimination in the Equality Act 2010 goes beyond safeguarding employees' religious beliefs to cover “philosophical beliefs” as well. Employees who hold a “philosophical belief” that meets the test set out in case law are protected against direct and indirect belief discrimination, harassment and victimisation because of their belief.

What constitutes a “philosophical belief” under the Equality Act 2010 is a matter of fact in each case. Employment tribunals will apply the test in Grainger plc v Nicholson, in which the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) set out five hurdles that must be jumped for a philosophical belief to come within the Equality Act 2010. The EAT found that a deeply held belief that “mankind is duty-bound to act on catastrophic climate change” was protected under the Equality Act 2010.


Isopix/REX/Shutterstock.

Belief in proper use of public money can be philosophical belief

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) ordered the employment tribunal to reconsider whether or not a claimant’s philosophical belief in the...

Elaine voted leave because she felt the EU was too bureaucratic, but now her colleagues say she's racist

Brexit: four bullying and harassment scenarios

12 Jul 2016

The result of the EU referendum has revealed divisions between different age groups and education levels, with feelings running high...

Continue Reading Comments { 0 }
Can employers insist on their staff wearing or not wearing a poppy in the workplace?

Wearing a poppy in the workplace: myth or reality?

4 Nov 2015

Employers often make the headlines over their policy on staff wearing a poppy in the workplace. We set out the...

Continue Reading
Sunday trading

Sunday trading: how employers can avoid the pitfalls

28 Aug 2015

Following a consultation launched by the Government, will employers be able to lawfully compel staff to work additional hours? Lloyd...

Continue Reading
Does public service broadcasting serve a "higher purpose"? Photo: REX/London News Pictures

Test yourself: Which non-religious beliefs have been protected by discrimination laws?

29 Jul 2014

We round up an eclectic list of beliefs that claimants have argued constitute “philosophical beliefs” under equality legislation before employment tribunals...

Continue Reading
Philosophical belief

Tribunal watch: Worker argues frustration over wasted public money is philosophical belief

21 Jul 2014

Can a public sector worker's passionate view that his employer should not waste public money count as a "philosophical belief" under discrimination legislation?

Continue Reading
The Holocaust memorial, Berlin. REX/WestEnd61

Tribunal watch: Holocaust denial not a belief protected by discrimination legislation

30 Jun 2014

Two more employment tribunal decisions, featured in our weekly round-up of tribunal cases in the press, can be added to...

Continue Reading
employee-rights

What can employers do if an employee’s rights conflict with another’s beliefs?

16 Jun 2014

In our increasingly pluralistic society it is inevitable that the beliefs of some will come into conflict with the rights...

Continue Reading
Marks and Spencer's food hall

Accommodating employees’ religious beliefs – should employers follow M&S’s example?

20 Jan 2014

The recent coverage of Marks & Spencer’s policy of allowing its members of staff to refuse to serve customers trying...

Continue Reading
The Labour Party Conference 2013. Photo: REX/Ray Tang

Labour party activist’s political views accepted as philosophical belief

10 Dec 2013

A Labour party activist has succeeded in having his political views recognised as a philosophical belief under the Equality Act 2010.

Continue Reading
wpid-tribunal.jpg

Can anti-Semitism count as a ‘philosophical belief’ under the Equality Act 2010?

4 Jul 2013

An employment tribunal has judged that a teacher’s anti-Semitic views are not protected as a “philosophical belief” under the Equality...

Continue Reading
wpid-nadia-eweida.jpg

EHRC publishes guidance on religion and belief in the workplace following Eweida ruling

15 Feb 2013

The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has published new guidance on managing religion and belief in the workplace, in...

Continue Reading
wpid-leeanne.jpg

How philosophical beliefs are protected against discrimination

26 Nov 2012

The recent case of Redfearn v The United Kingdom, which has in some places been abbreviated as the case of...

Continue Reading
wpid-legal.jpg

Tribunal awards: which discrimination cases attract the biggest payouts?

12 Sep 2011

While the latest Employment Tribunal Service statistics show that the average tribunal awards for age discrimination claims nearly tripled in...

Continue Reading

Weekly dilemma: Religion or belief discrimination

6 Jul 2011

One of my non-religious employees has been distributing literature at work – and messages on our intranet – promoting an...

Continue Reading