week’s letters

of the Week
Remember older can mean wiser

read your feature on the new breed in HR (13 March) with a sense of wonderment,
that Personnel Today could appear to champion the cause of ageism. By implication,
your article writes off an old breed of HR as Luddites, incapable of harnessing
the benefits of technology. 

find it mildly insulting to our profession that teamworking and exercising
autonomy appear to be put forward as the province of youth, as is being
Web-savvy, mobile and unconcerned for the mores of dress. Or am I overreacting
and feeling my age?

and incidentally, unlike Eileen Wood, I don’t mind receiving a fountain pen for
Letter of the Week (Letters, 13 March), but I’d as soon have a new stylus for
my Palm.

HR manager, Claverham

up for the written word

the letter in your 13 March issue, I think a fountain pen is quite apt. A
fountain can go with the flow yet still come to a useful point. Wordprocessing
packages cannot always convey the same message – the pen is mightier than the

Personnel Today on paper seems acceptable and I hope my birthday cards do not
arrive by e-mail. Of course technology is useful, but it is not the answer to

Training manager, Royal West Sussex NHS Trust

staff left to worry about future

wholeheartedly support the CIPD’s demand for the Government to consider the
views of HR specialists when reviewing redundancy consultation.

maybe companies about to embark on a downsizing operation would benefit from
consulting with those experienced in the process, in particular methods used to
support staff through the trauma of redundancy.

read with interest the article on Corus (News profile, 20 February) when Allan
Johnston said that “he would like to see consultation take place where it has
the most effect – which is generally in the workplace. If you are someone in
Port Talbot or Scunthorpe, what you really want to know is, ‘What the hell is
going on in my plant?”

also said they wished to deal with “people consequences” through a combination
of counselling and retraining.

have to tell Mr Johnston that the employees in Llanwern are saying, “What the
hell’s going on at my plant?” Most have so far received just one piece of paper
asking if they would like to be considered for “cross-matching” (redeployment),
and if they would like counselling. This was received some weeks ago and since
then they have received little information from management or unions.

appears to be no support, no information regarding government funding for
retraining, and calls to HR have been met with a complete lack of response.

employee’s view is that the plant is operating almost to full capacity, no 2
blast furnace has been taken out of mothballs, and it is once again producing
the finest quality steel in the world. The employees are perplexed at receiving
little or no information and feel unsupported and stressed.

Mr Johnston and his team like to share best practice?

Job search centre adviser, Rolls-Royce
See News pages for Allan Johnston’s response

access more vital than details

Wild’s article on Internet recruitment raised some interesting points, but
missed some key issues (Opinion, 27 February).

this year we ran a major research project into Internet use among 5,500
jobseekers in Europe. We found the greatest barriers to usage are the cost and
slow connectivity – each cited by two-thirds of the sample. Fast ISDN lines and
access at work mean many were searching for new jobs from the office.

of content was a lesser issue with 35 per cent saying they would access job
sites more often if it was easier to find information.

message is clear. Until infrastructure providers deliver better services and
telecoms providers slash access costs, employers will be denied access to a
vast audience of potential recruits.

Bernard Hodes Group

for fathers is a positive start

am pleased that the Government is going to introduce two weeks’ paid paternity
leave (News, 27 February). This is definitely a step in the right direction and
long overdue, as current arrangements are pretty poor.

should be allowed a decent amount of time off when their child is born. It is a
great help to know there is someone to take the kids to school, do a bit of
shopping and so on, especially when mums have to spend a short time
recuperating and looking after the new arrival – this might be an old-fashioned
thing to say, but it’s true.

everyone is lucky enough to have other family members to help out, so a couple
of weeks’ paid leave for a partner is a good start to family-friendly policies.

Part-time administrator, Plumstead   

Comments are closed.