UK no more biased against migrant workers than other EU nations

UK Brexiteers are more welcoming of migrant workers than the headlines and political rhetoric would have us believe
Frank Augstein/AP/REX/Shutterstock

Around 15% of people in the UK would object to having immigrants as neighbours, and most Brexiteers do not object to foreign workers, according to a new academic paper.

A study by Professor Mariah Evans of the University of Nevada, Reno (UNR), analysed major public surveys of human beliefs and values in the UK and other EU nations.

Published in the journal Frontiers in Sociology, the study found that prejudice against migrant workers was perhaps rarer in the UK than in other countries, despite media focus on some UK citizens’ apparent prejudice against immigrants.

“In the media turmoil surrounding Brexit, many pundits have seized on the prejudice angle, but these data demonstrate that is not actually what makes the UK different from the Continent,” argued Prof Evans.

“Prejudice against immigrant workers or minority ethnic and religious groups is rare in the UK, perhaps even slightly rarer than in equivalently developed EU countries.

“Even though only a small minority is prejudiced, in a large population that still makes many people – enough to show up in anti-immigrant demonstrations or to mobilise letter-writing campaigns to MPs.”

Researchers looked at responses to the World and European Values Surveys, which have around 500,000 combined respondents, as well as other quality of life surveys.

The aim was to look at how prejudices vary between nations at different stages of socio-economic development, and how prevalent prejudice was in the UK compared with other EU countries at a similar level of economic development.

Professor Evans added: “We found a high level of tolerance for ethnic and religious diversity is typical of prosperous European and Anglophone nations, whereas ethnic and religious prejudice is much more common in poor countries.”

The researchers describe the UK’s level of prejudice as being “stock standard” for a country of its wealth. “Just like their wealthy EU peers, around 15% of Britons would object to having immigrants as neighbours, around 10% would object to neighbours of a different race, and 10% would rather not have neighbours of a different religion,” she explained.

The analysis also showed that across all nations, prejudice tends to be either against all minority ethnic and religious groups or against none.

Dr Jonathan Kelley, an adjunct professor at UNR and director of the International Social Science Survey, said that prejudices tended to be linked together in the same way everywhere.

“For example, people who would shun immigrants as neighbours would also shun neighbours of a different religion and neighbours of a different race,” he said. “People who are good with one group as neighbours tend to be good with all. Prior researchers have suspected this, but this is the first time it has been demonstrated.”

The researchers argued that while data can go out of date quickly, they “provide a much more rational and accurate barometer of public opinion than do anti-immigrant demonstrations or political rhetoric”.

“There are many ways in which Britain is known to be ‘exceptional’ in the European context, but prejudice against immigrants is clearly not one of them,” added Dr Kelley.

As a corollary, events leading people to feel more warmly towards one minority will increase their warmth towards others, the research found.

Prof Evans added: “Equally promising, the strong gradient of prejudice decreasing with national development – economic growth and institutions that support personal freedom and markets – suggests that contrary to fashionable belief, modernisation is a powerful force for good as far as tolerance for diversity is concerned.”

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply