Personnel Today
  • OHW+
  • Join
  • Resources
    • Clinical governance
    • Disability
    • Ergonomics
    • Health surveillance
    • OH employment law
    • OH service delivery
    • Research
    • Return to work and rehabilitation
    • Sickness absence management
    • Wellbeing and health promotion
  • Conditions
    • Mental health
    • Musculoskeletal disorders
    • Blood pressure
    • Cancer
    • Cardiac
    • Dementia
    • Diabetes
    • Respiratory
    • Stroke
  • CPD
  • Webinars
  • OHW Awards
  • Jobs
  • Personnel Today

Personnel Today

Register
Log in
Personnel Today
  • OHW+
  • Join
  • Resources
    • Clinical governance
    • Disability
    • Ergonomics
    • Health surveillance
    • OH employment law
    • OH service delivery
    • Research
    • Return to work and rehabilitation
    • Sickness absence management
    • Wellbeing and health promotion
  • Conditions
    • Mental health
    • Musculoskeletal disorders
    • Blood pressure
    • Cancer
    • Cardiac
    • Dementia
    • Diabetes
    • Respiratory
    • Stroke
  • CPD
  • Webinars
  • OHW Awards
  • Jobs
  • Personnel Today

Financial servicesHR transformationHybrid workingUnconscious biasSectors

Daniel Kahneman: how ‘noise’ damages decisions

by Adam McCulloch 17 May 2021
by Adam McCulloch 17 May 2021 Unless carefully planned, meetings are liable to result in poor decisions according to Danel Kahneman.
Photo: Shutterstock
Unless carefully planned, meetings are liable to result in poor decisions according to Danel Kahneman.
Photo: Shutterstock

The return to the office needs to be accompanied by a radically new outlook from employers and employees so that we avoid falling into the same patterns of behaviour that in the past led to poor decision-making.

Nobel prize-winning author and psychologist Professor Daniel Kahneman told the BBC on Radio 4’s Start the Week this morning that as workers returned to the office it was essential to improve our evaluation of behaviour and understand the discordance between actions and words.

Financial journalist Gillian Tett, meanwhile, explored how using anthropological approaches would improve our reasoning at work in the post-lockdown era.

Wherever there is judgement there is noise and more of it than you think” – Prof Kahneman

Kahneman introduced the concept of “noise”, the subject of his latest book, which he describes as the variability in decisions made by people. Investigating to what extent decisions were uniform he studied the work of insurance firms’ underwriters, who when given with the same facts often came to completely different conclusions to those that the company’s executives had expected, much to their surprise. To further illustrate this he used a US study of 208 judges who were presented with the same 16 cases. One would have expected, he said, the judges to broadly agree what the sentences should be in the cases. But despite an average of seven years there was wide divergence of more than three years in sentencing decisions. “Wherever there is judgment there is noise and more of it than you think,” he said.

Psychology and hybrid working

Performance: Why ‘rank and yank’ fell out of favour

Writing a hybrid working policy: a guide for HR

Planning the future of your workplace: Six things for HR to consider

Mutual trust between managers and staff boosts performance

Links between psychological and physical safety

Employees look to avoid snooping employers

Similar studies had shown decision-making to be similarly random in other spheres, said Kahneman. Physicians tended to give different kinds of decisions when presented with the same symptoms at different times of day, with more antibiotics being prescribed in the afternoon. Temperature also affected decision-making with judges passing more severe sentences on hot days. He described this variability, or noise, as “unacceptable” and something businesses needed to tackle as they reset after lockdown. Like bias, it led to unnecessary errors.

One of the reasons why noise was so prevalent in organisations was because the amount of agreement in meetings was “much too high” because of the pressure for conformity from the leader or the person who speaks first or most confidently. As a result, decisions in meetings often did not “reflect the true diversity of opinion around the table”. Instead, people should be invited to share their own judgments prior to meetings “so people are aware of the amount of noise that they must bridge to reach a consensual decision”.

Recruitment was “really troubled” by noise, said Kahneman. A single person making decisions about candidates was usually convinced they were making the right decision, because they were unaware of noise, he said. When you have multiple people making the hiring decision it was vital to have independence. Independence was key if you wanted to gauge authentic judgments and opinions free of external influences. Both noise (variable error) and bias (an average bias) contributed equally to inaccurate decisions, he added.

Algorithms and simple rules were noise free, said the professor. If they were unbiased, using algorithms would improve decision-making, he said. “When algorithms are biased it is somebody’s fault …the person who made them. But they should be noise-free. Algorthmic bias is attracting a lot of attention but people in many ways were even more biased. People are both biased and noisy,” he told the programme.

We’ve fooled ourselves that business is all about numbers, balance sheets and data sets” – Gillian Tett, FT journalist

Listening to Kahneman was Ann Cairns, executive vice chair of Mastercard. She said that “noise” had led to far too few women being appointed to senior positions. Simply by maintaining independence from the hiring decision-making process and asking HR managers why so few women were being recruited or promoted and requesting that they reflect on their own thought processes she was able to reflect positive change.

Author of new book Anthro Vision and US managing editor of the FT Gillian Tett was also involved in the discussion. She described the return to the office as “an extraordinary opportunity to rethink our assumptions and notice things we never noticed before”. Citing the Chinese proverb “fish can’t see water”, Tett told BBC Radio 4 today that anthropology offered methods of improving decision-making and of avoiding the mistakes of the past. “Lockdown has shaken up everything,” she said, adding that office workers would “feel like Martians landing on Earth for the first time. “Look around you and try to see the things that you didn’t used to talk about,” she said.

A trained anthropologist herself, Tett explained how attending a financiers’ conference in France 15 years ago was analogous to attending a wedding ritual among tribal peoples in Tajikstan. She said: “You have a tribe of bankers using rituals and symbols to reinforce their world view and their social networks. The problem comes when the unstated assumptions take over and prevent people from seeing what’s hidden in plain sight.”

The “problem” in this case was the global financial crash of 2008, which Tett was one of few to correctly predict.

“Anthropology makes the familiar look strange and the unfamiliar look familiar,” she said. She noted how Kit Kat sales in Japan had surged for reasons unknown to manufacturer Nestlé. It transpired that students were using Kit Kats as a good luck symbol in exams. “People were interpreting Kit Kats in different ways.” Such findings had led to organisations now using anthropologists to analyse themselves and global markets.

Tett said that as people returned to offices it would be wise for leaders to reflect on the nature of meetings. Some people thought meetings were called merely to rubber stamp decisions, she said, others thought they were for forming a consensus. At General Motors an anthropologist was brought in to find out why teams were not agreeing on progress about a new car design. “It was because the three groups involved each had a different view of what meetings were for,” she said.

“We’ve fooled ourselves that business is all about numbers, balance sheets and data sets,” Tett added. “We ignore what the word ‘company means’. We all assume ourselves as rational with individual agency and linear thoughts. But our choices are affected by the people are around us and a much wider context that we don’t always see. Fish can’t see water.” She warned that as people became re-immersed in the company culture back in the office that wider context which may have appeared more visible during lockdown would be ignored.

Latest HR job opportunities on Personnel Today

Browse more human resources jobs

Adam McCulloch
Adam McCulloch

Adam McCulloch is a freelance writer and production editor who has worked in sectors including travel (The Guardian), aviation (Flight International), agriculture (Farmers' Weekly), music (Jazzwise), theatre (The Stage) and social work (Community Care). He also works for a national newspaper and is the author of KentWalksNearLondon

previous post
Crucial collective bargaining case reaches Supreme Court
next post
CPD: Workplace trauma post-pandemic (webinar)

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

You may also like

How an understanding of mental workload can boost...

12 Jan 2022

How to let employees go remotely – and...

10 Dec 2021

Sharp divisions emerge between leaders and workers over...

6 Aug 2021

Unpicking the links between psychological and physical safety

7 May 2021

Mutual trust between managers and staff boosts performance

27 Apr 2021

Performance: Why ‘rank and yank’ fell out of...

26 Feb 2021

Why building resilience should be a priority in...

12 Jan 2021

How to influence emotions to get the best...

28 Dec 2020

Will Covid spell the end of hierarchy? 

2 Dec 2020

Building skills the top priority for HR leaders...

16 Nov 2020

  • NSPCC revamps its learning strategy with child wellbeing at its heart PROMOTED | The NSPCC’s mission is to prevent abuse and neglect...Read more
  • Diversity versus inclusion: Why the difference matters PROMOTED | It’s possible for an environment to be diverse, but not inclusive...Read more
  • Five steps for organisations across the globe to become more skills-driven PROMOTED | The shift in the world of work has been felt across the globe...Read more
  • The future of workforce development PROMOTED | Northumbria University and partners share insight...Read more
  • Strathclyde Business School expands its Degree Apprenticeship offer in England PROMOTED | The University of Strathclyde is expanding its programmes...Read more
  • The Search for Talent: Six Major Employer Pitfalls PROMOTED | The Great Resignation continues unabated...Read more
  • Navigating the widening “Skills Confidence Gap” in 2022, and beyond PROMOTED | Cornerstone OnDemand conducted a global study...Read more
  • Apprenticeships are the solution to your recruitment problems PROMOTED | Apprenticeships have the pulling power...Read more

PERSONNEL TODAY

About us
Contact us
Browse all HR topics
Email newsletters
Content feeds
Cookies policy
Privacy policy
Terms and conditions

JOBS

Personnel Today Jobs
Post a job
Why advertise with us?

EVENTS & PRODUCTS

The Personnel Today Awards
The RAD Awards
Employee Benefits
Forum for Expatriate Management
OHW+
Whatmedia

ADVERTISING & PR

Advertising opportunities
Features list 2022

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin


© 2011 - 2022 DVV Media International Ltd

Personnel Today
  • OHW+
  • Join
  • Resources
    • Clinical governance
    • Disability
    • Ergonomics
    • Health surveillance
    • OH employment law
    • OH service delivery
    • Research
    • Return to work and rehabilitation
    • Sickness absence management
    • Wellbeing and health promotion
  • Conditions
    • Mental health
    • Musculoskeletal disorders
    • Blood pressure
    • Cancer
    • Cardiac
    • Dementia
    • Diabetes
    • Respiratory
    • Stroke
  • CPD
  • Webinars
  • OHW Awards
  • Jobs
  • Personnel Today