Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • Brightmine
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Free trial
    • Request a quote
  • Webinars
  • Advertise
  • OHW+

Personnel Today

Register
Log in
Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • Brightmine
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Free trial
    • Request a quote
  • Webinars
  • Advertise
  • OHW+

Case lawNHSFixed-term contracts

ECJ: do not use fixed-term contracts for permanent needs

by Lisa Hodgson 9 Dec 2016
by Lisa Hodgson 9 Dec 2016 There are approximately 50,000 temporary healthcare posts in Madrid. Design Pics Inc/REX/Shutterstock.
There are approximately 50,000 temporary healthcare posts in Madrid. Design Pics Inc/REX/Shutterstock.

A European Court of Justice (ECJ) case challenged the legality of Spanish legislation that permits the renewal of fixed-term contracts to cover permanent staff needs. Lisa Hodgson, employment senior associate at DLA Piper, explains.

Fixed-term contracts

How to employ an individual on a fixed-term contract

At what point does a series of successive fixed-term contracts become permanent?

Fixed-term contracts: employment law manual

Lόpez v Servicio Madrileño de Salud

Facts

Ms Maria Elena Pérez Lόpez, a Spanish national, was employed as a nurse at the University Hospital of Madrid on a fixed term-contract from 5 February 2009 to 31 July 2009.

The reason for her appointment was to provide “certain services of a temporary, auxiliary or extraordinary nature”.

Ms LÏŒpez’s employment was subsequently renewed seven times under identical contracts of three, six or nine months’ duration.

As a result, she was employed without interruption between 5 February 2009 and 31 March 2013.

On 28 January 2013, Spain’s Regional Ministry of Economic Affairs and Finance of Madrid issued an order imposing the termination of the employment relationships of occasional staff at the end of the appointment period, including where the individual was subsequently reappointed.

Shortly before Ms LÏŒpez’s contract expired, she was informed she would be reappointed, but that her employment relationship would cease. She brought an appeal against this decision, arguing that:

  • her successive appointments were not intended to meet a temporary, auxiliary or extraordinary need;
  • the Spanish legislation infringes an overriding objective of the European Framework Agreement regarding fixed-term contracts; and
  • as a result, her employment relationship should be reclassified as permanent.

The Administrative Court in Madrid decided to stay the proceedings and refer the case to the ECJ.

It asked the ECJ whether or not the Spanish legislation encourages abuse arising from the use of successive appointments and conflicted with an overriding objective of the Framework Agreement.

ECJ decision

The ECJ noted that the Framework Agreement requires member states to place limits on the use of fixed-term contracts to prevent abuse of such contracts.

While the ECJ stated that it was up to the member states to implement this overriding objective, it stated that the national implementing legislation should provide:

  • evidence of objective grounds on which the renewal of a fixed-term contract may be justified;
  • a total maximum duration for which such contracts may be concluded successfully; or
  • the number of possible renewals permitted for such contracts.

Seeing as Spanish legislation does not dictate prescribed limits in respect of duration or renewal (points two and three of the above list), the ECJ examined whether or not an objective ground relating to precise and concrete circumstances could justify the successive appointments of Ms Lopez (point 1 of the above list).

The ECJ acknowledged that temporary replacement of workers to satisfy temporary needs “may” constitute an objective ground.

It also considered that in the public-health sector, it is inevitable that temporary replacements will be necessary due to the unavailability of members of staff.

This could be because of sickness absence and maternity leave, and the temporary replacement of workers in such circumstances would be justified.

However, the ECJ considered that fixed-term contracts cannot be renewed for fixed and permanent tasks that normally come under the activity of ordinary hospital staff.

The objective ground must be able to justify the requirement to cover temporary needs and not permanent needs.

Implications for employers

This case highlights a conflict between the provisions of a European Framework Agreement and a national implementing measure.

The ECJ’s conclusion that the Spanish legislation compromised the objective of the Framework Agreement will have a significant impact on its healthcare industry and entrenched employment structure.

The ECJ estimated that approximately 50,000 medical and healthcare posts in Madrid alone are occupied by temporary staff, some of whom have been providing services continuously for 15 years. This decision puts that structure under threat.

Sign up to our weekly round-up of HR news and guidance

Receive the Personnel Today Direct e-newsletter every Wednesday

OptOut
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

In view of the potentially far-reaching consequences of this decision in other Spanish industries with similar employment structures, it may be that Spain and other EU member states take steps to crystallise the number of possible renewals permitted for fixed-term contracts.

UK legislation limits the number of renewals for fixed-term contracts. UK law provides that an employee who is continuously employed for four years or more on successive fixed-term contracts is automatically deemed to be a permanent employee.

Lisa Hodgson

previous post
Expedia retains top spot as best place to work in Glassdoor’s Employee Choice Awards
next post
How to make new performance management models work

You may also like

NHS 10-year Health Plan sets out vision for...

3 Jul 2025

One in eight senior NHS managers from black...

1 Jul 2025

Barts nurse told to remove watermelon image claims...

19 Jun 2025

Number of new nurses from abroad falls by...

18 Jun 2025

Overseas dentists ‘working in McDonald’s’ due to backlog

18 Jun 2025

Spending Review: ‘Much-needed’ cash but ‘little on workforce’

11 Jun 2025

School’s bid to appeal Kristie Higgs ruling refused...

11 Jun 2025

Healthdaq: Shaking up health and social care recruitment

11 Jun 2025

Two-thirds of workers still struggling to access GPs...

10 Jun 2025

Nurses vote on whether 3.6% pay rise is...

9 Jun 2025

  • Empowering working parents and productivity during the summer holidays SPONSORED | Businesses play a...Read more
  • AI is here. Your workforce should be ready. SPONSORED | From content creation...Read more

Personnel Today Jobs
 

Search Jobs

PERSONNEL TODAY

About us
Contact us
Browse all HR topics
Email newsletters
Content feeds
Cookies policy
Privacy policy
Terms and conditions

JOBS

Personnel Today Jobs
Post a job
Why advertise with us?

EVENTS & PRODUCTS

The Personnel Today Awards
The RAD Awards
Employee Benefits
Forum for Expatriate Management
OHW+
Whatmedia

ADVERTISING & PR

Advertising opportunities
Features list 2025

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin


© 2011 - 2025 DVV Media International Ltd

Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • Brightmine
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Free trial
    • Request a quote
  • Webinars
  • Advertise
  • OHW+