Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • Brightmine
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Free trial
    • Request a quote
  • Webinars
  • Advertise
  • OHW+

Personnel Today

Register
Log in
Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • Brightmine
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Free trial
    • Request a quote
  • Webinars
  • Advertise
  • OHW+

Personnel Today

Face it: competency theories don’t work

by Personnel Today 5 Dec 2000
by Personnel Today 5 Dec 2000

Bad HR
theories never die, they only fade away. Shaky concepts and basic design flaws
are put down to “difficulties in implementation”.

We choose
to keep such theories alive rather than face the fact that we have ardently
pursued something that has promised so much, yet achieved so little. And
because of the personal and professional credibility invested in such ventures,
we are unlikely to admit openly that the theory just does not work.

There are
several contenders for the worst HR theory title but the concept of management
competencies is top of my list. But then, we all knew this at the outset
because we even debated whether to call them “competences” or “competencies” –
an obvious indication of a poorly developed methodology.

The
practice of management competencies always presented many insuperable problems.
First, find a group of high-performing managers. Next, analyse their skills,
behaviours, aptitudes and so on (competencies) and find a cluster that sets
them apart. Then, analyse all managers’ competencies to identify where they are
deficient and use this as a basis for individual development plans. Meanwhile,
link your reward system to competencies and keep your fingers crossed that
there is a correlation between competence development and business performance.

One
sensible test of any new theory is to view it in the negative. So, is the
negative of competence “incompetence”? In other words, is competence a black or
white issue or is there a grey area called semi-competence? In this case, would
you like to be flown by a semi-competent pilot or be operated on by a
semi-competent surgeon? Should managers be allowed to manage before they are
totally competent? What if a particular bit of the jigsaw is always missing?

The biggest
flaw in competence theory is the specious concept that the best-performing
managers must have something in common. Any management population will exhibit
just as many differences as similarities and the biggest differentiators of all
– drive, judgement, leadership and initiative – are precisely the things that
are innate and less amenable to development.

We have
heard all these arguments before but did we ever hear any convincing answers?
Maybe it’s time to re-frame the basic proposition. The perfect manager does not
exist and no two managers are identical.

Perhaps the
focus of managerial development should not be a blueprint of perfect
competencies but individual, measured, managerial performance. Maybe we have to
accept the reality of managerial imperfections and aim for higher performance
levels within such constraints.

Sign up to our weekly round-up of HR news and guidance

Receive the Personnel Today Direct e-newsletter every Wednesday

OptOut
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

The theory
and practice of competencies have not delivered and any validity they may have
had is fading fast. The kindest thing would be to put them out of their misery
so that we can make a fresh start.

By Paul
Kearns, Senior partner, Personnel Works

Personnel Today

Personnel Today articles are written by an expert team of award-winning journalists who have been covering HR and L&D for many years. Some of our content is attributed to "Personnel Today" for a number of reasons, including: when numerous authors are associated with writing or editing a piece; or when the author is unknown (particularly for older articles).

previous post
Teacher wins stress claim award
next post
GCHQ desperately seeking staff

You may also like

Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders receive 400% pay rise

4 Jul 2025

FCA to extend misconduct rules beyond banks

2 Jul 2025

‘Decisive action’ needed to boost workers’ pensions

2 Jul 2025

Business leaders’ drop in confidence impacts headcount

2 Jul 2025

Why we need to rethink soft skills in...

1 Jul 2025

Five misconceptions about hiring refugees

20 Jun 2025

Forward features list 2025 – submitting content to...

23 Nov 2024

Features list 2021 – submitting content to Personnel...

1 Sep 2020

Large firms have no plans to bring all...

26 Aug 2020

A typical work-from-home lunch: crisps

24 Aug 2020

  • Empowering working parents and productivity during the summer holidays SPONSORED | Businesses play a...Read more
  • AI is here. Your workforce should be ready. SPONSORED | From content creation...Read more

Personnel Today Jobs
 

Search Jobs

PERSONNEL TODAY

About us
Contact us
Browse all HR topics
Email newsletters
Content feeds
Cookies policy
Privacy policy
Terms and conditions

JOBS

Personnel Today Jobs
Post a job
Why advertise with us?

EVENTS & PRODUCTS

The Personnel Today Awards
The RAD Awards
Employee Benefits
Forum for Expatriate Management
OHW+
Whatmedia

ADVERTISING & PR

Advertising opportunities
Features list 2025

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin


© 2011 - 2025 DVV Media International Ltd

Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • Brightmine
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Free trial
    • Request a quote
  • Webinars
  • Advertise
  • OHW+