Tribunal claims remain dramatically down for third consecutive quarter

Frances O'Grady
TUC general secretary Frances O'Grady. Photo: REX/Mark Thomas

Employment tribunal receipts continue to record a dramatic year-on-year decline, according to the latest round of quarterly statistics from the Ministry of Justice.

The number of single tribunal claims received in April to June 2014 was 3,792 – 70% fewer year-on-year and one-third down on the previous quarter. The number of multiple claims also fell, down 85% year-on-year.

Tribunal-awards

The decline will continue to be correlated with the introduction in July 2013 of employment tribunal fees, but the introduction in April 2014 of the Acas early conciliation scheme is also now a significant contributing factor to the fall.

The decrease in employment tribunal claims will lend weight to Unison’s Court of Appeal hearing next week, in which it is challenging the introduction of fees.

Sex discrimination claims have fallen by the largest margin with only 591 claims in April to June 2014 versus 6,310 in the same period in 2013, a fall of 91%.

TUC general secretary Frances O’Grady said: “Early conciliation through Acas is a welcome step that is helping in some cases when things go wrong at work, but it can’t explain such a large fall in the number of employment tribunals. The fees system is a victory for Britain’s bad bosses who are getting away with harassment and abuse of workers.

“Tribunal fees are pricing workers out of justice and have created a barrier to basic rights at work. The Government has put Britain in a race to the bottom that is creating an economy based on zero hours jobs and zero rights for workers.”

Fergal Dowling, partner at law firm Irwin Mitchell, said: “These figures come as no surprise and reflect a downwards trend in employment tribunal numbers.

“Many will attribute the fall to the introduction of early conciliation in April, but Unison, which is currently involved in a legal challenge about the impact on fees, will no doubt believe it adds weight to its argument that fees indirectly discriminate against protected groups such as women, ethnic minorities and disabled people and are unlawful.

“Recent calls for the scrapping of employment tribunal fees by the Labour Party need to be balanced by the needs of business, but we believe the time is right to review the systems and ensure it is operating in a fair way for all.”

Earlier this week the Labour party said it would scrap the current “unfair” employment tribunal system.

3 Responses to Tribunal claims remain dramatically down for third consecutive quarter

  1. stargraves 12 Sep 2014 at 3:43 pm #

    The fees directly discriminate – this is hateful, offensive, and unethical. Totally reflective of an ideology that targets those with the least as easy victims. Despicable policy that only sociopaths could implement.

  2. Martin W. 15 Sep 2014 at 9:21 am #

    Of course it’s down to the fees – anyone who believes otherwise is deluding themselves. The rules discrimate against the most vulnerable in our society, and are yet another example of how this government is determined to undermine the rights of the employee in favour of increasing further the wealth of the few.

  3. Jason G 19 Sep 2014 at 12:08 pm #

    As an employer we have faced 7 tribunal claims, 3 never even made it to tribunal and of the 4 that did we won comfortably because there was no real case to answer. I believe the rules have stopped time wasters chancing their arms to get something for nothing. Those that really feel wronged will still proceed and for those without the financial ability to pay the fees are waived so how can it be unfair?