Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
    • Advertise
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Equality, diversity and inclusion
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • XpertHR
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Pricing
    • Free trial
    • Subscribe
    • XpertHR USA
  • Webinars
  • OHW+

Personnel Today

Register
Log in
Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
    • Advertise
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Equality, diversity and inclusion
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • XpertHR
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Pricing
    • Free trial
    • Subscribe
    • XpertHR USA
  • Webinars
  • OHW+

Dispute resolutionCase lawConstructive dismissalDisciplineDiscipline and grievances

Personality clashes in the workplace: five interesting employment cases

by Stephen Simpson 27 Feb 2015
by Stephen Simpson 27 Feb 2015 Is an employee's personality a reason for dismissal?
Is an employee's personality a reason for dismissal?

Personality clashes are the third most common cause of workplace conflict, according to an XpertHR survey. In what circumstances can an employer take action when colleagues simply don’t get on? Stephen Simpson rounds up five cases in which a personality clash led to dismissal.

1. Competent but unpleasant executive dismissed for “some other substantial reason”

Perkin v St George’s Healthcare NHS Trust (Court of Appeal)

Personality clashes in the workplace

Podcast: Personality clashes XpertHR senior employment law editors Jeya Thiruchelvam and Stephen Simpson discuss how employers should deal with personality clashes in the workplace.

This is the leading case on dismissals for personality clashes. The Court of Appeal considered the dismissal of an executive after senior colleagues raised concerns about his abrasive manner and management style. His competence was not in question.

The Court of Appeal backed the employment tribunal decision that, although the dismissal was procedurally unfair, the executive’s behaviour, including making unfounded accusations against colleagues, justified the reduction of his compensation to zero.

The case confirms that an employee’s personality is capable of being a potentially fair reason for dismissal, provided that the employee’s actions can be brought within the ambit of “conduct” or “some other substantial reason”.

2. Dismissal of employee unpopular for incessant sexual boasting

CA Treganowan v Robert Knee & Co Ltd (High Court)

This is a well-known decision from 1975 on personality clashes. A competent member of staff fell out with junior colleagues over her permissive attitude to relationships and constant discussion of her sexual conquests. The employer dismissed the claimant after things got so bad that her colleagues refused to work with her and the business was affected.

The High Court dismissed an appeal against the tribunal decision that, on the facts, dismissal was the only reasonable course of action.

3. Younger manager felt threatened by more experienced subordinate

Kessell v Passion for Perfume Ltd (employment tribunal)

The claimant, who was older and more experienced than her manager, was dismissed after only two months’ employment. The claimant had raised the issue of a personality clash between herself and her manager.

The employment tribunal found that she was dismissed because she was seen by her younger female manager as a threat. The employment tribunal believed that the reason for the personality clash was age-related. The claimant was awarded more than £11,000 in compensation for age discrimination.

What are the most common reasons for individual conflict in the workplace?

Workplace conflict survey 2011: levels and causes Find out what employers say are the reasons most commonly quoted by employees for individual conflict. “Personality clashes” comes third.

4. Dismissal of one of two former friends who “fell out badly” was fair

Mealing v Edmonds t/a The Gatehouse Diner (employment tribunal)

In this case, a small employer had to deal with a familiar problem: what to do if employees’ behaviour becomes unprofessional because they have fallen out with each other.

Two colleagues who had been friends “fell out badly” and “ceased to speak to each other”. Things became so bad between the pair that disciplinary action was initiated against them both. One employee’s behaviour improved, but the other’s (the claimant’s) did not. The claimant was dismissed after further warnings, with her behaviour towards her colleague given as the reason for dismissal.

The tribunal found that the employer’s procedure was flawed, but that the claimant’s behaviour was so bad that she should not receive any compensation. The tribunal rejected the claimant’s argument that it was unfair for the employer to dismiss one employee, but not the other: one employee’s behaviour had improved, but the claimant had refused to modify her behaviour.

5. Employee unfairly dismissed after complaints from colleague “out to get him”

Byrne v Warburtons Ltd (employment tribunal)

The claimant had a managerial style that he admitted was “not modern”, with a tendency to shout and swear at people when he was not happy. A number of disagreements arose between the claimant and a black colleague. It was clear to everyone that the two men did not get on.

The claimant’s colleague made various allegations of racism, with the decision to dismiss being made following a workplace investigation into a comment that the claimant did “not like black people” when he was a schoolboy because of bullying.

The tribunal upheld the claimant’s unfair dismissal claim. It concluded that, although the employer had a zero-tolerance policy on racism, it had failed to take account of the two men’s history of bickering. The tribunal suggested that the claimant’s colleague had been “out to get him”.

Avatar
Stephen Simpson

Stephen Simpson is a principal employment law editor at XpertHR. His areas of responsibility include the policies and documents and law reports. After obtaining a law degree and training to be a solicitor, he moved into publishing, initially with Butterworths. He joined XpertHR in its early days in 2001.

previous post
Occupational health profile: Hilary Winch, director of Syngentis and OH head at Norwich University Hospital
next post
How should HR respond to the Fit for Work service (assuming they’ve heard of it)?

You may also like

Employers face three days of disruption as train...

31 May 2023

Royal Mail dispute: postal union pauses vote on...

25 May 2023

Covid-resignation driving examiner to have tribunal claim reheard

19 May 2023

Embryologist unfairly dismissed after whistleblowing

18 May 2023

Strikes bill passes House of Lords after amendments

10 May 2023

Law firm partner fined £45k for lewd song

10 May 2023

Employers urged to limit alcohol at work parties

9 May 2023

£3m award for unfairly dismissed Isle of Man...

4 May 2023

Top 10 HR questions April 2023: Bank holiday...

3 May 2023

CBI apologises for recruiting ‘toxic’ staff

25 Apr 2023

  • The HR Bundle: Your one-stop guide to building a successful global HR Department PROMOTED | Get your hands on Deel’s free HR bundle...Read more
  • The Benefits of an Employee Assistance Programme PROMOTED | EAPs support employees in a range of ways...Read more
  • Intergenerational working and how to manage up and down the generations PROMOTED | The benefits and challenges of intergenerational workplaces...Read more
  • Bereavement in the workplace: How training can help HR get it right PROMOTED | HR professionals play an essential role...Read more
  • UK workforce mental wellbeing needs PROMOTED | The mental wellbeing support employers are providing misses the mark...Read more

Personnel Today Jobs
 

Search Jobs

PERSONNEL TODAY

About us
Contact us
Browse all HR topics
Email newsletters
Content feeds
Cookies policy
Privacy policy
Terms and conditions

JOBS

Personnel Today Jobs
Post a job
Why advertise with us?

EVENTS & PRODUCTS

The Personnel Today Awards
The RAD Awards
Employee Benefits
Forum for Expatriate Management
OHW+
Whatmedia

ADVERTISING & PR

Advertising opportunities
Features list 2023

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin


© 2011 - 2023 DVV Media International Ltd

Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
    • Advertise
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Equality, diversity and inclusion
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • XpertHR
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Pricing
    • Free trial
    • Subscribe
    • XpertHR USA
  • Webinars
  • OHW+