Personnel Today
  • OHW+
  • Resources
    • Clinical governance
    • Disability
    • Ergonomics
    • Health surveillance
    • OH employment law
    • OH service delivery
    • Research
    • Return to work and rehabilitation
    • Sickness absence management
    • Wellbeing and health promotion
  • Conditions
    • Mental health
    • Musculoskeletal disorders
    • Blood pressure
    • Cancer
    • Cardiac
    • Dementia
    • Diabetes
    • Respiratory
    • Stroke
  • CPD
  • Webinars
  • Jobs
  • Personnel Today

Personnel Today

Register
Log in
Personnel Today
  • OHW+
  • Resources
    • Clinical governance
    • Disability
    • Ergonomics
    • Health surveillance
    • OH employment law
    • OH service delivery
    • Research
    • Return to work and rehabilitation
    • Sickness absence management
    • Wellbeing and health promotion
  • Conditions
    • Mental health
    • Musculoskeletal disorders
    • Blood pressure
    • Cancer
    • Cardiac
    • Dementia
    • Diabetes
    • Respiratory
    • Stroke
  • CPD
  • Webinars
  • Jobs
  • Personnel Today

Case lawLatest NewsHealth and safetyVicarious liability

Tarmac not liable for injury resulting from ‘horseplay’, rules Court of Appeal

by Ashleigh Webber 12 Jan 2022
by Ashleigh Webber 12 Jan 2022 The Court of Appeal found that Tarmac Cement and Lime was not liable for an employee's prank
Kay Roxby / Alamy
The Court of Appeal found that Tarmac Cement and Lime was not liable for an employee's prank
Kay Roxby / Alamy

The Court of Appeal has ruled that Tarmac Cement and Lime cannot be held vicariously liable for a practical joke one of its employees played on a contractor, which damaged his hearing.

Mr Chell, who was employed by another company, claimed he suffered tinnitus and noise induced hearing loss in his right ear and after one of Tarmac’s employees, Mr Heath, placed two pellet targets next to his ear and hit them with a hammer, causing a loud explosion, while he was working at Tarmac’s site in Brayston Hill quarry, Shropshire, in 2014.

Chell argued that Tarmac should be held vicariously liable for the actions of its employee, and claimed that it breached its duty to take steps to prevent a foreseeable risk of injury.

In 2019, the High Court dismissed both of Chell’s claims. Chell’s appeal against the decision was heard at the Court of Appeal in November 2021.

Today (12 January) Lady Justice Nicola Davies dismissed the appeal, stating that there was “no reasonably foreseeable risk of injury” that arose from the practical joke played by Mr Heath.

“It is accepted that horseplay, ill-discipline and malice could provide a mechanism for causing such a reasonably foreseeable risk but, in my view, it is not made out on the facts of this case,” the judgment says.

Vicarious liability

Vicarious liability: Employer not liable for injury caused by employee’s “practical joke”

Supreme Court: Employer not vicariously liable for rogue employee’s data breach

“If it is seriously suggested that there should have been a specific instruction not to engage in horseplay, I regard the same as unrealistic. Common sense decreed that horseplay was not appropriate at a working site. The fitters were employed to carry out their respective tasks using reasonable skill and care, and by implication to refrain from horseplay.”

The judgment says it would have been “unreasonable and unrealistic” to expect an employer to have a system in place to ensure that their employees did not engage in horseplay.

“Further, the general site rules include a section that ‘No one shall intentionally or recklessly misuse any equipment’. This was a warning against exactly what Mr Heath did,” it adds.

Had the Court of Appeal found for the claimant, employers would have been forced to reconsider their entire risk assessments and would have had to take unreasonable measures to avoid risk of injury from horseplay at the workplace” – Tim Riordan, CMS

Tim Riordan, a personal injury partner at law firm CMS, who acted in the case, said: “This was a crucial decision which rejected the notion that employers are responsible for the consequences of employee practical jokes at the workplace.

“Had the Court of Appeal found for the claimant, employers would have been forced to reconsider their entire risk assessments and would have had to take unreasonable measures to avoid risk of injury from horseplay at the workplace.”

Joe Aiston, an employment senior associate at law firm Taylor Wessing said the Court of Apppeal’s decision was “common sense”.

“The acts in question are clearly unrelated to the employee’s assigned responsibilities, a practical joke gone wrong, so the employer is not liable,” he said.

“However, this leaves this injured party, and any other similar future cases, in a potential legal black hole, unable to seek recourse from anyone for injuries genuinely sustained in a workplace. There are also likely to be scenarios where the assessment of whether an employee’s actions were carried out in the course of their employment is more debatable and an employer may be at risk of being held vicariously liable.

Sign up to our weekly round-up of HR news and guidance

Receive the Personnel Today Direct e-newsletter every Wednesday

OptOut
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

“The decision does not, however, mean employers have no duty to protect the health and safety of its employees and third parties who may work on site. All employers should ensure they are fully aware of their health and safety responsibilities and that their policies and procedures are fully up to date.”

Latest HR job opportunities on Personnel Today


Browse more human resources jobs

Ashleigh Webber

Ashleigh is a former editor of OHW+ and former HR and wellbeing editor at Personnel Today. Ashleigh's areas of interest include employee health and wellbeing, equality and inclusion and skills development. She has hosted many webinars for Personnel Today, on topics including employee retention, financial wellbeing and menopause support.

previous post
Union urges government to reverse fit note relaxation
next post
Cleaner who attended work with Covid-19 was unfairly dismissed

You may also like

New law could make it easier for organisations...

8 Apr 2024

Employer found liable for sexual misconduct at party

31 May 2023

Worker injured in practical joke cannot take vicarious...

22 Sep 2022

Seven key employment law cases from 2020

17 Dec 2020

How Covid-19 has added to ‘insider threat’ risks

7 Jul 2020

Barclays not liable for sexual assaults committed by...

2 Apr 2020

Six employment law cases that will shape 2020

14 Jan 2020

Supreme Court hears final Barclays appeal in sexual...

28 Nov 2019

Morrisons’ vicarious liability appeal reaches Supreme Court

6 Nov 2019

Morrisons data leak: implications for employers

2 May 2019

  • 2025 Employee Communications Report PROMOTED | HR and leadership...Read more
  • The Majority of Employees Have Their Eyes on Their Next Move PROMOTED | A staggering 65%...Read more
  • Prioritising performance management: Strategies for success (webinar) WEBINAR | In today’s fast-paced...Read more
  • Self-Leadership: The Key to Successful Organisations PROMOTED | Eletive is helping businesses...Read more
  • Retaining Female Talent: Four Ways to Reduce Workplace Drop Out PROMOTED | International Women’s Day...Read more

Personnel Today Jobs
 

Search Jobs

PERSONNEL TODAY

About us
Contact us
Browse all HR topics
Email newsletters
Content feeds
Cookies policy
Privacy policy
Terms and conditions

JOBS

Personnel Today Jobs
Post a job
Why advertise with us?

EVENTS & PRODUCTS

The Personnel Today Awards
The RAD Awards
Employee Benefits
Forum for Expatriate Management
OHW+
Whatmedia

ADVERTISING & PR

Advertising opportunities
Features list 2025

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin


© 2011 - 2025 DVV Media International Ltd

Personnel Today
  • OHW+
  • Resources
    • Clinical governance
    • Disability
    • Ergonomics
    • Health surveillance
    • OH employment law
    • OH service delivery
    • Research
    • Return to work and rehabilitation
    • Sickness absence management
    • Wellbeing and health promotion
  • Conditions
    • Mental health
    • Musculoskeletal disorders
    • Blood pressure
    • Cancer
    • Cardiac
    • Dementia
    • Diabetes
    • Respiratory
    • Stroke
  • CPD
  • Webinars
  • Jobs
  • Personnel Today