Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • Brightmine
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Free trial
    • Request a quote
  • Webinars
  • Advertise
  • OHW+

Personnel Today

Register
Log in
Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • Brightmine
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Free trial
    • Request a quote
  • Webinars
  • Advertise
  • OHW+

Rest periodsNHSHR softwarePayroll softwareLatest News

Court of Appeal: Junior doctor wins rest break test case

by Rob Moss 31 Jul 2019
by Rob Moss 31 Jul 2019 Royal Derby Hospital. Photo: Rui Vieira/PA Archive/PA Images
Royal Derby Hospital. Photo: Rui Vieira/PA Archive/PA Images

The NHS faces a bill of millions of pounds after a junior doctor won a test case yesterday about the way a hospital trust monitored rest breaks.

Dr Sarah Hallett and 20 colleagues who trained with her said that Derby Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust failed to ensure that the doctors took regular breaks nor that they were paid for extra work undertaken.

The Derby hospitals, which are now part of University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust (UHDB), will have to repay the doctors around £250,000 for underpayments over an eight-month period but the judge ruled that the cost for the wider NHS is “potentially substantial”.

Commercially available workforce rostering software known as Allocate, used at Derby, is widely embedded across the NHS to monitor rest break compliance.

Staff monitoring

When does keeping tabs on working time overstep the line?

Last month, just a fortnight before the hearing, health secretary Matt Hancock attempted to intervene in the case because of the “considerable” financial implications.

Doctors union, the British Medical Association, which supported the case, described the ruling as a “significant victory”.

Dr Jeeves Wijesuriya, chair of the BMA junior doctors committee, said: “[Yesterday’s] ruling is a victory for junior doctors and confirms that trusts or health boards have been using commercial software that has underestimated the hard work, long hours and inadequate rest faced by junior doctors for years.

“In overturning last year’s ruling, the Court of Appeal has established a binding precedent in England and Wales in favour of the BMA regarding how monitoring of junior doctors on the 2002 contract should be done.

“The doctor supported by the BMA in the case, Dr Sarah Hallett, is not seeking compensation. Our objective has always been to establish the correct interpretation in the law to both protect patient safety and the interests of junior doctors.”

Dr Hallett described the victory as “bittersweet” in a tweet.

Over 4 years after starting to look into my case, this is something of a bittersweet victory today. It should not have needed to escalate to this level to confirm the importance of accurately assessing if junior doctors are getting breaks. https://t.co/RpJU6sy2Lb

— Sarah Hallett (@DrSarahHal) July 30, 2019

The case centres on whether the hospital complied with its contractual obligation to allow junior doctors to take 30-minute natural breaks after approximately four hours’ continuous duty.

NHS trusts are financially incentivised to comply with rest break requirements and other controls on hours and intensity of working. Where staff monitoring demonstrates non-compliance junior doctors are entitled to a Band 3 supplement, a “double time” pay rate.

Dr Magnus Harrison, UHDB executive medical director, said: “Patient safety is central to everything we do in our hospitals and we work hard to ensure excellent training, alongside a good work life balance, for our junior doctors.

“However, this decision clearly has implications not only for the trust but other NHS employers. It is important that we reflect carefully on the judgment and whether it should be appealed. We are working closely with our legal representatives and relevant stakeholders and we will make a decision in due course.”

Lord Justice Bean ruled that Derby Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust’s method of calculation, which assessed whether natural breaks were compliant using expected data instead of recorded data, was “both in breach of the contract on its proper interpretation and also irrational”.

Dr Wijesuriya added: “For those junior doctors on the 2002 contract, banding plays a vital role in ensuring trusts or health boards do not run overly fatiguing or unsafe rotas. Yet the widespread use and incorrect application of monitoring software resulted in trusts failing to pick up issues with working conditions, and potentially weakening the protections afforded to junior doctors in their contracts.

“These protections were put in place because it is recognised that junior doctors working long hours, in a system under pressure, with no provision for even a short break will be left exhausted.

“Throughout this case the BMA been clear that is it vitally important that working hours and the ability to take breaks are properly monitored, rotas are compliant, and sanctions enforced where trusts or health boards have not ensured that there are safe working practices in place.”

Sign up to our weekly round-up of HR news and guidance

Receive the Personnel Today Direct e-newsletter every Wednesday

OptOut
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

UHDB has until 9 August to appeal to the Supreme Court. At the time of publication Allocate Software was preparing a statement.

HR Director opportunities on Personnel Today

Browse more HR director jobs

Rob Moss

Rob Moss is a business journalist with more than 25 years' experience. He has been editor of Personnel Today since 2010. He joined the publication in 2006 as online editor of the award-winning website. Rob specialises in labour market economics, gender diversity and family-friendly working. He has hosted hundreds of webinar and podcasts. Before writing about HR and employment he ran news and feature desks on publications serving the global optical and eyewear market, the UK electrical industry, and energy markets in Asia and the Middle East.

previous post
When is an employer liable for an employee’s Facebook post?
next post
Burger King’s beard ban violated workers’ rights, Catalan authorities rule

1 comment

Graham 9 Aug 2019 - 5:44 pm

Chamberlain – v- Cambridge and Peterborough Foundation Trust (Fulborn Hospital) is identical case where the ET found the NHS guilt and ordered full compensations to paid off to the four claimants junior doctors

Comments are closed.

You may also like

RCN warns Darlington NHS trust over single-sex spaces

16 May 2025

NHS Scotland staff accept two-year 8.2% pay deal

16 May 2025

Healthcare workers prioritise mental health support in new...

12 May 2025

Nurses threaten strikes if pay demands not met

12 May 2025

Jobs on the line across NHS trusts in...

9 May 2025

NHS worker awarded £29k after Darth Vader comparison

8 May 2025

Resident doctors to ballot for strike action

2 May 2025

NHS Lothian review finds ‘toxic’ work environment

2 May 2025

Public sector staff could be in line for...

28 Apr 2025

Call for better mental health support for NHS...

17 Apr 2025

  • 2025 Employee Communications Report PROMOTED | HR and leadership...Read more
  • The Majority of Employees Have Their Eyes on Their Next Move PROMOTED | A staggering 65%...Read more
  • Prioritising performance management: Strategies for success (webinar) WEBINAR | In today’s fast-paced...Read more
  • Self-Leadership: The Key to Successful Organisations PROMOTED | Eletive is helping businesses...Read more
  • Retaining Female Talent: Four Ways to Reduce Workplace Drop Out PROMOTED | International Women’s Day...Read more

Personnel Today Jobs
 

Search Jobs

PERSONNEL TODAY

About us
Contact us
Browse all HR topics
Email newsletters
Content feeds
Cookies policy
Privacy policy
Terms and conditions

JOBS

Personnel Today Jobs
Post a job
Why advertise with us?

EVENTS & PRODUCTS

The Personnel Today Awards
The RAD Awards
Employee Benefits
Forum for Expatriate Management
OHW+
Whatmedia

ADVERTISING & PR

Advertising opportunities
Features list 2025

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin


© 2011 - 2025 DVV Media International Ltd

Personnel Today
  • Home
    • All PT content
  • Email sign-up
  • Topics
    • HR Practice
    • Employee relations
    • Learning & training
    • Pay & benefits
    • Wellbeing
    • Recruitment & retention
    • HR strategy
    • HR Tech
    • The HR profession
    • Global
    • All HR topics
  • Legal
    • Case law
    • Commentary
    • Flexible working
    • Legal timetable
    • Maternity & paternity
    • Shared parental leave
    • Redundancy
    • TUPE
    • Disciplinary and grievances
    • Employer’s guides
  • AWARDS
    • Personnel Today Awards
    • The RAD Awards
  • Jobs
    • Find a job
    • Jobs by email
    • Careers advice
    • Post a job
  • Brightmine
    • Learn more
    • Products
    • Free trial
    • Request a quote
  • Webinars
  • Advertise
  • OHW+