Graduate recruitment heats up, salaries stay frozen

Employers have frozen graduate starting salaries for the eighth year in a row, despite an overall pick-up in graduate recruitment, latest XpertHR Benchmarking research finds.

Graduate recruitment activity is recovering, with 86% of UK employers recruiting or having already recruited graduates in 2016/2017. This reverses the dip seen one year ago, when the proportion of employers looking to hire graduates fell to three-quarters.

Fewer than half (45%) of employers seeking graduates in 2016/2017 are planning to take on more graduates than they did one year ago. Across the whole economy, only one employer in 10 is seeking fewer graduates than last year. But this rises to 27% for public-sector employers.

While graduate recruitment is accelerating, graduate starting salaries are not following suit.

For an eighth successive year, XpertHR has recorded a headline increase of nil for graduate starting salaries.

Seven in 10 organisations have frozen graduate starting salaries for 2016/2017 at last year’s levels.

Among the minority raising graduate starting salaries, the most common increase is 2%, with most ranging between 1% and 3%.

Median graduate starting salary holds at £23,000

The median graduate starting salary for 2016/2017 is £23,000. This is unchanged from the rate recorded by XpertHR in 2015, but is down from £23,500 two years ago.

By sector, graduates joining manufacturing-and-production firms in 2016/2017 can expect the highest median starting salaries, at £24,900. In contrast, median graduate starting salaries are set at £23,000 in private-sector services and £22,000 in the public sector.

However, a minority of private-sector organisations are taking a more competitive stance on graduate starting salaries. “To get good quality graduates in certain roles we are having to pay a lot more in terms of starting salary,” said one manufacturing firm. One employer in 10 is offering a graduate starting salary of £29,000 or higher. The highest graduate starting salary for 2016/2017 is £45,000.

With the overall picture for graduate starting salaries static, more than half of private-sector organisations are using additional reward elements to enhance their offering.

The most common additional reward element offered to graduates in 2016/2017 is participation in a bonus scheme during the first year of employment, joining golden hello payments and car allowances.

Graduate recruitment methods

Employers are using a wide range of graduate recruitment methods to attract candidates. The most common are the organisation’s corporate website, links with universities, university careers services, and social media.

The use of social media to recruit graduates shows particularly strong growth in the public sector, where it is used by three-quarters of respondents. This is up from just over half in 2015/2016. It is likely that this rapid growth reflects the need to explore lower-cost options for sourcing graduates in the light of public spending cuts. However, only one public-sector respondent in 10 pointed to social media as the most effective means of attracting graduates.

Across the whole sample, employers cite job boards as the most effective candidate attraction method for graduate recruitment, with around half of respondents using them.

Nine employers in 10 recruiting graduates in 2016/2017 rate their organisation as effective or very effective at recruiting and selecting high-quality graduates. This is up from four-fifths one year ago. Public-sector employers are significantly more likely than those in the private sector to rate themselves as effective or very effective.

Quantity and quality of graduates

Despite this high level of confidence, 85% of employers have experienced problems with graduate recruitment. The most common problem is poor-quality applicants, cited by nearly half (46%).

Many graduates are not of graduate calibre, argued one private-sector-services respondent: “The quality is poor, especially in terms of basic skills such as being able to write a covering letter.”

Sign up to our weekly round-up of HR news and guidance

Receive the Personnel Today Direct e-newsletter every Wednesday

Email(Required)

OptOut

From time to time, we will send you emails about selected products, events and services from Personnel Today and OHW+ - but you can choose to opt-out at any time. If you do not wish to receive these emails, please tick this box.

Email

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Δ

The next most common graduate recruitment problem is a lack of applicants, mentioned by 38% of employers. “University fees have driven down the number of people going on to study at degree level, leading to a dip in applicant numbers,” said a private-sector-services employer.

The rise of portfolio careers could also be starting to have an impact on the graduate labour market, with some employers seeing a poorer return on investment from graduates. “Our experience is that new graduates very rarely stay in their first (or even second and third) jobs for very long,” said one respondent. “This can make recruiting them a very expensive process when measured against their productivity in the role.”

• The 27th annual XpertHR Benchmarking survey on trends in graduate recruitment and starting salaries is based on responses from 273 organisations with a combined workforce of 799,348 employees, and a combined expected intake for 2016/2017 of 4,616 graduate recruits. Subscribers to XpertHR Benchmarking can access the complete results data on graduate recruitment and graduate starting salaries.